Key Takeaways

  • The top 5 roofing materials for Indiana homes are asphalt shingles, metal, cedar shake, slate, and synthetic options.
  • Your ideal choice depends on budget, curb appeal, maintenance needs, and Indiana’s weather conditions.
  • Strenova Exteriors provides expert guidance and free, detailed estimates to help you choose the right roofing material.

When it comes to exterior home upgrades, few decisions carry more weight (literally and financially!) than your roof. Selecting the best roofing materials for your Indiana home isn’t just about looks. It’s about long-term protection, energy savings, resale value, and how well your home stands up to the state’s varied climate.

This guide to roofing materials covers everything you need to know, from how to choose the right roofing material for your unique home and budget to what our experts believe are the top 5 roofing materials to consider for your home.

Why Your Roofing Material Matters More Than You Think

Your roof is your home’s first line of defense. The right roofing material can mean fewer repairs, better insulation, and a longer lifespan. It also directly impacts:

  • Durability: Resistance to wind, rain, hail, snow, and UV damage
  • Energy efficiency: Improved insulation can lower heating and cooling costs
  • Curb appeal: The right material complements your home’s architecture and increases resale value

Indiana’s unpredictable climate, including our freezing winters, humid summers, and storm seasons, makes material choice even more crucial. 

To skip the stress, reach out to our team at Strenova Exteriors for a free consultation. We’ll tell you what you need!

What Are the Best Roofing Materials for Homes in Indiana?

What are Strenova’s top 5 roofing materials homeowners in Indianapolis and surrounding areas should consider? Let’s dive in:

1. Asphalt Shingles (Most Popular & Budget-Friendly)

  • Pros: Affordable, widely available, easy to install
  • Cons: Shorter lifespan than premium options, may need more maintenance
  • Lifespan: 15–30 years
  • Best for: Budget-conscious homeowners looking for a reliable, traditional solution

2. Metal Roofing (Durable & Weather-Resistant)

  • Pros: Extremely durable, energy-efficient, low maintenance
  • Cons: Higher upfront cost, potential noise during storms
  • Lifespan: 40–70 years
  • Best for: Long-term homeowners or those in storm-prone areas of Indiana

3. Cedar Shake Roofing (Rustic & Natural Appeal)

  • Pros: Natural insulation, standout aesthetics, environmentally friendly
  • Cons: Requires regular maintenance, not fire-resistant unless treated
  • Lifespan: 20–40 years
  • Best for: Upscale or historic homes in neighborhoods that allow wood roofing

4. Slate Roofing (Elegant but Expensive)

  • Pros: Beautiful appearance, fire-resistant, incredibly long-lasting
  • Cons: Heavy, expensive, not suitable for all roof structures
  • Lifespan: 75–100+ years
  • Best for: Luxury homes or historic restorations with strong roof framing

5. Synthetic Roofing (Modern Solutions for Any Home)

  • Pros: Mimics slate or wood look, lightweight, cost-effective
  • Cons: Still new in some markets, quality can vary
  • Lifespan: 30–50 years
  • Best for: Homeowners who want premium looks without the premium price tag

The best roofing materials for your Indianapolis-area home depend on variables like your goals, budget, and willingness or ability to conduct maintenance. Here’s a visual breakdown:

Roofing Material Comparison Table

Material Avg. Lifespan Cost ($-$$$) Maintenance Ideal For
Asphalt Shingles 15–30 years $ Low Most homeowners
Metal Roofing 40–70 years $$ Low Storm-prone or long-term homes
Cedar Shake 20–40 years $$$ Medium Upscale, rustic, or historic homes
Slate 75–100+ years $$$$ Low Luxury homes with strong roof structures
Synthetic 30–50 years $$ Low Style-savvy homeowners on a budget

How to Choose the Right Roofing Material for Your Home

A roof stripped of its shingles and awaiting new roofing materials

Choosing the right roof isn’t just about picking from a list. Instead, it’s about balancing priorities.

A clear picture of the why for remodeling your roof will act as a guide to the best roofing materials for your house. But, there’s still plenty more to consider!

Budget vs. Longevity: What Are You Really Paying For?

While asphalt shingles may cost less upfront, metal or synthetic roofing can last twice as long, saving money on replacements and repairs in the long run. Is financing an option? Consider both the short-term and long-term financial commitments.

Home Style & HOA Requirements

Choose a material that complements your home’s architecture. Some neighborhoods or HOAs may restrict options like cedar or metal, so even if you believe you’ve selected the best roofing materials, be sure to confirm approval with your HOA.

Maintenance Preferences & Lifestyle

Cedar shake may look great, but if you don’t want to commit to regular upkeep, a low-maintenance option like synthetic might be a better fit.

Repairing & Preventing Storm Damage

We’re no strangers to large hail and damaging winds here in Greater Indianapolis, and it’s important to consider how you can best address repairs with your chosen roofing materials while also preventing future damage.

Sustainability

If you’re looking to save money on energy costs and save the planet while you’re at it, a metal roof or “cool roof” made of special shingles could be the best choice. 

Resale Value & Curb Appeal

Higher-end materials like slate or metal can add resale value and help your home stand out in the market.

Local Insights: Roofing Materials That Work Best in Indianapolis

Indiana’s climate demands roofing materials that resist heavy snow, high winds, and UV exposure. Based on years of local experience, Strenova Exteriors often recommends:

  • Metal roofing for storm-prone suburbs like Avon, Plainfield, and Brownsburg
  • Asphalt shingles for cost-effective solutions in Indianapolis and Zionsville
  • Synthetic or composite shingles for homeowners who want a custom look with less upkeep

Whatever you choose, a detailed inspection and material-specific consultation can ensure the best outcome for your property.

Still Unsure? Here’s How Strenova Exteriors Can Help

A two-story home’s roof is being replaced by the Strenova team

If you’re not a roofing expert, attempting to choose the best roofing materials can be overwhelming. That’s why Strenova Exteriors offers highly detailed FREE estimates, including a full material breakdown and professional recommendations.

With dedicated project managers, transparent communication, and top-quality installation, we make the process seamless, from start to finish.

Request a Free Roofing Consultation Today

FAQ: Best Roofing Materials in Indiana

What is the best roofing material for a house in Indiana?

Metal roofing and high-quality asphalt shingles are top choices due to durability, weather resistance, and affordability.

What are the top 5 roofing materials you’d recommend?

Asphalt shingles, metal roofing, cedar shake, slate, and synthetic roofing.

Is metal roofing better than shingles for Indiana weather?

In storm-prone or rural areas, yes. Metal offers better wind and hail resistance, but asphalt may still be suitable for many homeowners.

How do I know when to replace my roof?

Look for missing shingles, granule loss, interior leaks, or roof age over 20 years. Get an inspection to be sure.

What roofing material lasts the longest?

Slate is the most durable, often lasting 75–100+ years. Metal is also a strong long-term option.