Key Takeaways:

  • Upgrade to Resilience: Consider impact-resistant asphalt or tough metal roofing over standard 3-tab shingles. They’re a better defense against Indianapolis weather.
  • Metal Strong: Metal roofs last longest. They’re the strongest roof material to withstand Midwest storms; resistant to wind speeds of up to 160 mph!
  • Composite = Beauty + Durability: Composite roofs mimic natural styles with the bonus of a Class 4 impact rating. They’re a terrific lightweight choice among the best roofing materials.
  • Insurance Simplified: Strenova Exteriors handles the initial roof inspection. We guide you through the post-storm damage insurance claims process.

Indianapolis’ weather is famously unpredictable, presenting an all-you-can-eat buffet of high winds, sudden hailstorms, and damaging freeze-thaw cycles. Such weather patterns can put your roof through the ringer. This leads to hidden damage that compromises your home’s structure. You never know which storm will be the one that forces your hand for expensive roof repair.

Here’s your opportunity to think of a roof replacement as a strategic investment, instead of just a cost. It’s an investment in your peace of mind and property value. Elevate your roof with the best roofing materials as the optimal way to create a truly resilient residence.

This guide explores how to select a high-performance roof built for a Midwest climate. Strenova Exteriors breaks down your options and helps you identify the most durable roof materials. Let’s ensure your place is protected for decades to come.

The Go-to Choice: High-Performance Asphalt Shingles

3-Tab shingles (characterized by three notches at the bottom edge) represent a basic, low-cost option that yields the classic brick pattern. They are single-ply and offer limited protection against the wind. Consider these upgrades:

Architectural Shingles: The Modern Standard

The asphalt shingle is still the most common residential roofing solution; however, today’s shingle is a major leap forward from yesterday’s 3-tab option. Modern architectural shingles (sometimes called laminate shingles) are beefier, with multiple layers. They create a dimensional look that adds depth and definition to your roofline.

Aesthetics are just one part of the picture; these shingles are engineered for superior defense against high winds (up to 130 mph). The layered design prevents uplift and detachment during storms. Laminate shingles are a popular and cost-effective choice when pondering the best roofing materials upgrade.

The Impact Resistance Factor (Class 4)

For Indianapolis and surrounding areas, where hailstorms are a regular (and pricy) threat, Class 4 impact-resistant shingles are the move. This designation results from rigorous testing where the material must withstand being hit from a two-inch steel ball dropped from 20 feet. If a shingle can handle that, it can handle impacts from hail. No cracks or tears!

Look for shingles with this rating to also resist premature granule loss caused by hail—critical for maintaining their waterproof substrate. Class 4-rated shingles are truly durable roof material options designed for storm survival. You may even qualify for a reduced insurance premium with these.

Metal Roofing: The Best Roofing Material for Longevity

House with light blue metal roof

For the ultimate in resilience, let’s get into metal and its advantages as the strongest roof material.

Unmatched Storm and Wind Performance

Metal roofing stands as the ultimate upgrade for resilience-minded homeowners; it’s the strongest roof material available today. These modern systems are engineered to take virtually everything the Midwest can throw at them, be it brutal winter ice or a blustery summer derecho. Unlike shingles, metal panels interlock tightly or through mechanical fasteners for better resistance to wind uplift.

Standard metal roofs are one of the best roofing materials thanks to their ability to withstand hurricane-level winds of up to 160 mph. Such roofs match a Class A fire rating with imperviousness to rot and pests. Your best bet is a metal roofing system for long-term safety and security.

Style Points and Energy Efficiency

What’s strength without style? Metal roofing offers a streamlined aesthetic for instant curb appeal elevation. Standing seam metal systems, for example, come in various hues with clean lines that complement any architectural style. Metal isn’t just about protection; it’s a transformational visual upgrade.

Metal is also one of the best roofing materials for energy savings and sustainability due to its inherent reflective properties. Specialized coatings on the surface divert solar radiant heat away from the house. That means significantly less heat is absorbed by your attic for lower cooling bills during a hot Indianapolis summer.

Cost and Maintenance Considerations

A new metal roof takes a bigger bite out of your pockets than an asphalt roof. Instead of seeing the expense, view it as an investment that pays off over time, as metal is one of the most durable roofing materials around. Given a usual lifespan of 40 to 70 years, you’ll likely never need another roof replacement.

There’s less maintenance with metal roofing. Asphalt shingles require regular repair and, in some cases, significant replacement; a metal roof only needs the occasional inspection and cleaning. Longevity and low upkeep make metal the champion for the best long-term roofing material.

The Premium Upgrades of Tile, Slate, and Composite Materials

Roofers installing a tile roof

Indianapolis-area homeowners aren’t limited to metal and asphalt. Consider these alternatives for the best roofing materials for a functional and beautiful upgrade.

Synthetic and Composite Excellence

Synthetic and composite shingles are a modern solution that hits on both fronts: fashion and function. They mimic the deep textures of natural slate or cedar shake skilfully without the high upkeep. Such composite roofs also achieve a Class 4 impact rating. These lightweight options allow for easier installation; they’re an accessible upgrade for any Indianapolis-area residence.

Natural Stone and Tile Options

Natural stone and tile represent the ultimate in timelessness in high-end home projects. They’re not as common here, but are worth serious consideration for locals aiming for a specific type of curb appeal, as well as the most durable roof materials:

  • Authentic Slate: Non-combustible and waterproof; lifespan in excess of 100 years with little maintenance
  • Clay and Concrete Tiles: Can withstand extreme temperatures; exceptionally resistant to fire

Installation of these options is highly specialized. Initial costs are substantial; however, these alternatives are some of the best roofing materials for long-term investment, driven by aesthetics.

Beyond the Shingle: Your Exterior Partners at Strenova

Many roof upgrades start with an insurance claim after storm damage. Strenova Exteriors is your trusted roofing partner to work closely with insurance adjusters. We deliver professional inspections to help you receive fair coverage for the damage.

Transforming your roof with the best roofing materials is the optimal defense against unpredictable weather in Indianapolis. Strenova is ready to upgrade your roof with the strongest roofing materials for long-term resilience and value. Request a free quote for your roof replacement now!